Wednesday, January 16, 2008

Techdirt: Do You Actually Understand What Copyright Is For?

 Techdirt: Do You Actually Understand What Copyright Is For?

"Draws together many of the recent posts explaining the history and background of copyright -- HSM"

 

Do You Actually Understand What Copyright Is For?

from the most-people-don't dept

One of the more amazing things I've discovered in discussing copyright, patents and trademarks with people is that very few people seem to know what each of those three sets of regulations are actually intended for. It certainly makes reasonable discussion and debate on any sort of reform difficult when a large percentage of people involved in the debate (or, tragically, writing the laws around those regulations) seem to believe the purpose of them is entirely different than it actually is. That's why we've tried to point to some historically interesting discussions on these regulations. Two recent blog posts pointed out something interesting related to all this. The first, comes (again) from copyright expert William Patry, who points to a seven minute video of ordinary people explaining why they think copyright exists. The video itself is by Karl Fogel, who also runs a site called Question Copyright. What the video pretty clearly demonstrates is that most people have no clue why copyright exists, and many assume (as we see in the comments around here) that it's there to "protect" the content creator or to prevent plagiarism. No one seems to note that its true purpose, as per the Constitution, is to promote progress (amusingly, many believe copyright is a much more recent creation).

Techdirt: Do You Actually Understand What Copyright Is For?

1 comment:

Karl Fogel said...

As I mentioned in a comment over at one of the original articles, the Constitution is a pretty poor guide for understanding the purpose(s) of copyright. Here's the comment:

http://www.techdirt.com/article.php?sid=20071230/233138#c543

Best,
-Karl Fogel